With L.A. Weekly apparently having cleared out their online archives, here's a repost from an article I wrote for them in 2017.
Enter the New Dim Sum Contender
The
past decade or so has produced a sea change in Chinese dining in Los
Angeles, as well as the rest of the United States. Decades of Cantonese
dining dominance have nearly evaporated as regional cuisines
representing the entire breadth of Chinese cooking have come to the
United States in great numbers, reflecting the migration of mainland
Chinese residents and money to our shores. Indeed, in recent years, new
Cantonese restaurant openings in the San Gabriel Valley have dwindled to
roughly 10 percent of total new Chinese restaurants opening in the SGV.
However,
while Cantonese food may be down, it is not out in our local Chinese
community. The toughest Chinese restaurant ticket continues to be the
most popular dim sum palaces on Saturday and Sunday afternoon, and the
greatest wish among Chinese diners is that, despite the high quality of
our local dim sum purveyors, some new dim sum player, equal to or better
than the existing dim sum leaders, will open its doors. In this regard,
it's disappointing that we have had the same leaders of the dim sum
pack for several years. As it has for the past 15 years, Sea Harbour in
Rosemead is on the top of most people’s dim sum list, followed variously
by Lunasia and King Hua in Alhambra, Happy Harbor in Rowland Heights
and Elite in Monterey Park, all of which date back to 2008 or earlier.
The only newcomer in the top tier of local dim sum is Arcadia’s China
Red, which opened in 2013, and it sits at the bottom of this top tier.
Not
that new operators haven’t tried to crack the top group. In 2014, Shi
Hai opened in Alhambra with the express purpose of becoming the top dog,
dim sum–wise, in the San Gabriel Valley. However that endeavor ended
unsuccessfully last year when Shi Hai rebranded as World Seafood, with a
new, lower-priced menu. Other dim sum palaces have opened in the same
period, such as Shanghai #1 Seafood Village in San Gabriel, Grand Harbor
in Temple City and Pleasure Ocean in Hacienda Heights, but while they
certainly purvey good dim sum, they do not match up to our historic
leaders.
However,
a newly opened restaurant in Temple City, though a bit on the small
side, may prove to be the new contender that everyone has been hoping
for. Xiang Yuan Gourmet opened last month and is already showing
great promise.
First of all, it serves its dim sum from a
menu, as does every other restaurant listed in this report. While
romantics may gush about dim sum carts representing the true dim sum
experience (although there was no such thing as a dim sum cart in Los
Angeles until introduced by Miriwa Restaurant in Chinatown in 1976), the
best dim sum comes from a menu since it arrives fresh and cooked to
order. Secondly, Xiang Yuan Gourmet shows a creativity and imagination
in some of its dim sum creations that is consistent with that found at
the top tier dim sum restaurants. While it is important that a dim sum
restaurant gets its har gow, BBQ pork buns, beef cheung fun rice noodle rolls, siu mai and
other favorites right, it is the unusual dish that sets the top-tier
dim sum restaurants apart — think bamboo shoot dumplings shaped like
carrots, mushroom buns and egg and seaweed rolls.
Other interesting dim sum items include sauteed chicken feet with chili and ginger, crispy seafood cheung fun, spare rib cheung fun, pork blood jelly with chives, and baked almond cream bun.
One
unique thing about Xiang Yuan Gourmet is the dinner menu. Every other
dim sum restaurant mentioned here serves Hong Kong–style seafood at
dinnertime, with the except of Shanghai #1 Seafood Village. However,
Xiang Yuan Gourmet’s dinner fare is a mixture of Hong Kong–style seafood
and “traditional Hunan cuisine"; this mix represents the direction of
Chinese food in the San Gabriel Valley these days.
9556 Las Tunas, Temple City; (626) 286-6788.